Mickey Mantle’s 1952 Topps card is #311, the first card of the set’s last series, and it is not his rookie card.
That is the 1951 Bowman #253. This is his first Topps card, from the company’s first large baseball set: 407 cards in six series, the first of them in stores in March 1952. Topps sold them five to a nickel pack with a slab of pink gum, under the words GIANT SIZE, and they were: about 2⅝ by 3¾ inches, larger than that year’s Bowmans. The fronts had color-tinted photographs, facsimile signatures and, for the first time, team logos. Sy Berger worked out the design with the artist Woody Gelman in the autumn of 1951.
Mantle is seen from the shoulders up, in a Yankees cap, the bat on his left shoulder, his eyes turned up and away against a blue sky. The Yankees’ top-hat logo sits in a box at the lower left, and his name and signature in a starred box beside it. The picture began as a 1951 news-agency photograph.
The sixth series, #311 to #407, came out in late summer, when buyers had turned to football. Sales were poor, and unsold cases went back to Brooklyn, where several hundred were still in the warehouse in 1960. That year, the story goes, Topps took them out on a barge and dumped them. PSA and Berger’s obituary put the barge in the Atlantic, Sports Collectors Digest quotes Berger on the Hudson, and one PSA article calls the whole thing hobby lore.
Left on Type 1, right on Type 2: the stitching on the back tells them apart.
The sheets held 100 cards and the series had 97, so three were printed twice: Mantle, Jackie Robinson at #312 and Bobby Thomson at #313. Mantle’s second version was redrawn almost from scratch, and collectors call the two Type 1 and Type 2. The baseball stitching on the back points left on Type 1 and right on Type 2; on the front, the last letter of the signature curls up only on Type 1. CGC labels them on its holders.
Mantle was twenty in 1952, an All-Star in center field, at .311 with 23 home runs. Ahead were the 1956 Triple Crown, three Most Valuable Player awards and 536 home runs. Centering is the card’s usual trouble, worst on copies cut from the corners of the sheet, along with wax stains from the pack.





