Guides for old, inherited and graded sports card collections

Most people arrive here holding something: a shoebox of cards from the 1970s, a parent’s collection, or a few graded cards they are thinking of selling. These guides are written for that moment. They cover how to sort an old baseball card collection, what to do with an inherited sports card collection before anything is sold, how PSA grading works and when it is worth paying for, where to sell sports cards and what each route costs, and how to document a collection so the next person understands it. Every guide is free, written by a collector, and dated when it was last updated.

1948 Leaf Jackie Robinson1952 Topps Mickey Mantle1958 Topps Jim Brown

Cards someone left you

A parent’s or grandparent’s collection, and a family deciding what to do with it.

1986 Fleer Michael Jordan1981 Topps Joe Montana2003 Topps LeBron James

Graded cards you may sell

Cards in PSA, SGC or Beckett holders, and a question about where they would do best.

Every guide · 13
If a collection has just come to youWhat to do with an inherited card collection — before you sell any of itThe first week, the first month, what you probably have, and the four different prices people will quote you. · 16 min readWhere to sell — fees, timing, and who to callEvery serious house side by side: what it costs to sell, when you get paid, and the named person who answers the phone. · 11 min readWhat Happens to the Tax Bill When Sports Cards Are InheritedThe one rule most families never hear about, why it changes what to do first, and what the record has to show. · 5 min readWhere to sell sports cards: every way, and what each one costsWhere to sell sports cards — an auction house, an online marketplace, eBay, a dealer, a card show or a private sale — and what each costs, how long it takes, and what kind of collection it suits. · 5 min readKeeping what you haveHow to document a collection — properly, and while you still canWhat a real record contains, the four things almost everyone leaves out, and what to do when it gets harder. · 7 min readHow to ship a valuable card — and get it backPacking a slab so it cannot move, what each carrier will and will not insure, how the graders send cards home, when to carry a card by hand instead — and, step by step, sending a PSA slab to MBA for a Diamond and getting it back. · 8 min readHow the market worksThe auction houses — every place to sell, side by sideWhat each handles, its premium, its next sale and deadline, and which of them are the same company. · 4 min readWhat a winning bid actually costs — buyer's premium at every houseAll nineteen side by side, read from each house's own published terms and dated. Put your own number in and see the total. · 4 min readThe auction calendar — every major sale, with its consignment deadlineWhen each house closes, when it stops taking consignments, and what it adds to the hammer. Checked at the house every week. · 3 min readHow PSA Grading Works: What the Slab MeansHow PSA grading works, step by step. Then authentication, the 1–10 scale, three graders that are really three markets, the grades that are not numbers, the letters after the grade, population reports, a second opinion on the first — and when the grade is not the story. · 12 min readHow to sort an old card collection in an afternoonShoeboxes, binders, rubber bands and no idea what matters. An order to work in, what to set aside first, and how to find the short pile worth a closer look. · 4 min readShould you grade a card before you sell it?When grading pays for itself, when it doesn’t, and a simple test to decide card by card without guessing at the grade. · 4 min readWhy cards from 1987 to 1993 usually aren’t worth muchThe years the hobby printed too many cards, why it still shapes what an old collection is worth, and the few exceptions worth finding. · 3 min read

The houses

Every house side by side — premium, next sale, deadline, and who owns whom →

General information for collectors and families. Nothing here is advice to buy or sell.