The Field Guide

The auction houses

Every place a serious sports card is bought and sold, side by side: what each one handles, what it adds to the hammer, when its next sale closes, and which of them are the same company. Choose one to see what it charges a seller, when it pays, and who to call.
19places to sell, each profiled
17.5–28%buyer’s premium at the auction houses
Dec 8next consignment deadline · Heritage Auctions
2pairs of houses that are one company

Auction houses

Listed alphabetically — never by fee, and no house pays to appear or to appear higher.

AltMarketplace that runs auctions · vintage and modernBuyer’s premium 20%Next sale not yet postedRhythm A new two-week auction opens every Friday, so one closes every Thursday β€” extended bidding from 9 PM ET.Fees, payouts and who to call →Christie'sAuction house · memorabiliaBuyer’s premium 28%Next sale not yet postedRhythm No regular sports calendar. Sports sales are occasional single-owner collections, chiefly game-used and historic memorabilia, several presented with Hunt Auctions.Fees, payouts and who to call →Clean Sweep AuctionsAuction house · vintageBuyer’s premium 22%Next sale Double Play Auction, closes Jan 7Rhythm Double Play (2-day, 2,000+ lots) plus showcase; monthly print catalogSame company as LelandsFees, payouts and who to call →Fanatics CollectMarketplace that runs auctions · vintage and modernBuyer’s premium 20%Next sale not yet postedRhythm Weekly auctions run ten days, opening Thursday and closing Sunday from 10 PM ET; a two-week Premier auction each month.Fees, payouts and who to call →GoldinAuction house · vintage and modernBuyer’s premium 22%Next sale Fall Combat Sports Auction, closes Nov 22+Rhythm Marketplace; Weekly closes Thursdays 10 PM ET; Elite ($500+ start, $7,500+ estimated)Fees, payouts and who to call →Grey FlannelAuction house · memorabiliaBuyer’s premium 22%Next sale not yet postedRhythm Catalog auctions through the year, with Premier Lots.Fees, payouts and who to call →Heritage AuctionsAuction house · vintage and modernBuyer’s premium 22%Next sale Sports Showcase Auction, closes Nov 21+Rhythm Platinum Night, Sports Card Signature, Showcase, weekly Sunday selectsFees, payouts and who to call →Huggins & ScottAuction house · vintageBuyer’s premium 20%Next sale Fall Auction, closes Dec 3Rhythm Three to four a year β€” February, May, August/September and November.Same company as Robert Edward AuctionsFees, payouts and who to call →Hunt AuctionsAuction house · memorabiliaBuyer’s premium 17.5%Next sale Internet Auction, closes Dec 2Rhythm Internet auctions through the year, live auctions at institutional events (e.g. the Louisville Slugger Museum & Factory), and a Winter Premier.Fees, payouts and who to call →LelandsAuction house · vintageBuyer’s premium 22%Next sale Fall Classic, closes Dec 5Rhythm Classic Auction 3x/yr, Pop-Up, Collectors First groupSame company as Clean Sweep AuctionsFees, payouts and who to call →Love of the Game AuctionsAuction house · vintageBuyer’s premium 20%Next sale Fall Premier Auction, closes Dec 12Rhythm 3 Premier sales/yrFees, payouts and who to call →Memory LaneAuction house · vintageBuyer’s premium 20%Next sale not yet postedRhythm ~3 Rarities sales/yr plus a 21-day fixed-price marketplaceFees, payouts and who to call →Mile High Card CompanyAuction house · vintageBuyer’s premium 22%Next sale not yet postedRhythm Summer/Fall Premium Catalog, Extra InningsFees, payouts and who to call →Robert Edward AuctionsAuction house · vintageBuyer’s premium 23% *Next sale Fall Catalog Auction, closes Dec 6Rhythm 3 catalog auctions plus monthliesSame company as Huggins & ScottFees, payouts and who to call →SCP AuctionsAuction house · vintageBuyer’s premium 20%Next sale not yet postedRhythm 3 Premier sales/yr plus standing Buy NowFees, payouts and who to call →Sotheby'sAuction house · vintage and modernBuyer’s premium 28%Next sale Winter Sports Marquee, closes Feb 16Fees, payouts and who to call →Wheatland Auction ServicesAuction house · vintageBuyer’s premium 18%Next sale December 2026 Vintage & Current Era Sports Card & Memorabilia Auction, closes Dec 13+Rhythm Approximately quarterly; exact dates are not published in advance.Fees, payouts and who to call →

Marketplaces you sell on yourself

A different job: nobody catalogs or markets the card for you, and the fees are lower because the service is smaller.

Go further

The auction calendar — every sale this season with its consignment deadline.
What a winning bid costs — each premium, with a calculator.
Every house’s fees on one printable page — to bring to the conversation.
Where to sell — what each house charges the seller, when it pays, and who answers the phone.
The Radar — follow any card across all of them, free.

Nothing here is a view on what any card is worth. We also buy cards ourselves; that has no bearing on this page. Where a house is marked with *, its premium is not published and the figure is our own — the fee page explains it.