Where to sell sports cards · Wheatland Auction Services

Selling sports cards through Wheatland Auction Services

Wheatland Auction Services is an auction house for vintage cards. What it costs to consign, when you are paid, the deadlines, and who to ask for.

In short. Wheatland Auction Services adds an 18% buyer’s premium to the hammer price. The seller’s commission is not published — it is negotiated per consignment. Sellers are paid 21–28 days after the sale. The smallest lot it takes is $150.

No house pays to appear here or to appear higher. What follows is what Wheatland Auction Services publishes, or has told us directly, with the date we last checked. It is not a recommendation, and nothing here is a view on what your cards are worth. We also buy cards ourselves; that has no bearing on anything written here.

What it costs to consign, and when you are paid

What it costs to sell
Not published Negotiated per consignment.
When you get paid
21–28 days after the sale Three to four weeks from the auction close date.
Smallest lot they take
$150 Typically around $150, and not set in stone.
Deadlines
No fixed deadlines — they work to the consignor's own timeline and are equipped to take last-minute additions to an auction.
How often they sell
Approximately quarterly; exact dates are not published in advance.
Ask for Stacey WhismanOwnerChuck WhismanOwner or info@wheatlandauctionservices.com confirmed by the house

What a buyer pays on top

The buyer's premium at Wheatland Auction Services is 18% of the hammer price. Flat. All bidders must have a major credit card on file. Pennsylvania sales tax where applicable.

It is paid by the winning bidder, not by you — but bidders know it is coming, so it shapes what they are willing to bid.

Buyer's premium at every auction house, side by side →

Before you call

Know roughly what is there first — which cards matter, and which are graded. Ask for the seller's commission in writing, ask whether anything else is charged (photography, insurance, return of unsold lots), and ask when you will be paid. Then ask at least one other house the same questions.

Compare every auction house →  ·  Every way to sell, and what each costs →  ·  Auction fees compared →  ·  Not sure it fits? Ask us where to sell it →

Wheatland Auction Services's own site →

Terms last checked 2026-08-12. Fee structures and schedules change; confirm anything that matters with Wheatland Auction Services.

All the auction houses, side by side →
Other places to sell: Alt · Christie's · Clean Sweep Auctions · Fanatics Collect · Goldin · Heritage Auctions · Huggins & Scott · Lelands · Love of the Game Auctions · Memory Lane · Mile High Card Company · MySlabs · Robert Edward Auctions · SCP Auctions · Sotheby's · eBay