Where to sell sports cards Β· Fanatics Collect

Selling sports cards through Fanatics Collect

Fanatics Collect is a marketplace that runs ten-day Weekly auctions and a two-week Premier auction each month, for vintage and modern cards. What it costs to consign, when you are paid, the deadlines, and who to ask for.

In short. Fanatics Collect adds a 20% buyer’s premium to the hammer price. There is no seller’s commission. Sellers are paid within 48 hours of the sale.

No house pays to appear here or to appear higher. What follows is what Fanatics Collect publishes, or has told us directly, with the date we last checked. It is not a recommendation, and nothing here is a view on what your cards are worth. We also buy cards ourselves; that has no bearing on anything written here.

What it costs to consign, and when you are paid

What it costs to sell
No seller's commission No seller's fee on Weekly or Premier auctions β€” the consignor is paid 110% of hammer up to $250,000, rising to 115% above $1m. The Buy Now marketplace inverts it: no buyer fee, and the seller pays 6% when the price is under 120% of the market value the site shows (from Card Ladder), 12% at or above it. A U.S. seller who chooses payment in FanCash, Fanatics' store credit, before listing pays no fee; FanCash can be spent across Fanatics but not withdrawn as cash.
When you get paid
Within 48 hours of the sale Once the buyer has paid β€” credited to the seller's Fanatics Collect account balance, to withdraw or spend.
Smallest lot they take
Not published
Deadlines
Not published
How often they sell
Weekly auctions run ten days, opening Thursday and closing Sunday from 10 PM ET; a two-week Premier auction each month.

What a buyer pays on top

The buyer's premium at Fanatics Collect is 20% of the hammer price. Applies to Premier and Weekly auctions alike. Buy Now marketplace items carry no buyer fee. A further 2.9% may apply depending on payment method and destination.

The winning bidder pays it, not you. Bidders know it is coming, though, so it shapes what they are willing to bid.

Buyer's premium at every auction house, side by side →

Upcoming auctions

Each date confirmed with Fanatics Collect. Every house's calendar →

Before you call

Know roughly what is there first: which cards matter, and which are graded. Ask Fanatics Collect whether anything else is charged (photography, insurance, the return of unsold lots), when the next consignment deadline is and how small a lot they will take. You will find the payment timing in the table above.

Compare every auction house →  ·  Every way to sell, and what each costs →  ·  Auction fees compared →  ·  Not sure it fits? Ask us where to sell it →

Fanatics Collect's own site →

Terms last checked 2026-08-22. Fee structures and schedules change; confirm anything that matters with Fanatics Collect.