Where to Sell Β· Private Acquisitions

Private acquisitions

We buy blue-chip graded baseball, basketball and football cards, and whole collections, from estates and inherited boxes to a lifetime of graded cards. If you are thinking of selling, we would like to hear from you.
Single cards, usually $5,000 and up

Graded by PSA, SGC or BGS. Photographs first, then in person or by insured shipment. Baseball, basketball and football only; for anything else, the auction houses we list are the better home.

Whole collections, too

Estates, inherited boxes, the shoebox that’s been in the closet since 1965. We’re most interested in cards from before 1980, stars in any condition, and anything already graded. Send a few photos and we’ll let you know if it’s a fit, and if it isn’t, where you’d do better.

Seen in person across Maryland, Delaware, Pennsylvania, Virginia, New Jersey, Washington, D.C. and nearby, or by insured shipment from anywhere.

How it works

  1. Tell us what you have. A few lines below are enough — a single card or a whole collection.
  2. We write back personally, usually within two business days, often with a question or two and a request for photographs.
  3. We review what you have. Graded cards by their certification numbers and photographs; a collection by list or photographs first, and in person when it helps.
  4. A written offer, card by card. Each figure sits beside the recent sales it rests on and what selling at auction would likely leave you after fees. Raw cards are offered on as they are; nothing needs grading first. The offer holds for 14 days, and we encourage a second opinion. If a card would likely do better at auction, we will tell you so, and which house.
  5. If you accept, the handover. In person, or by insured shipment: we send you a prepaid, fully insured shipping label, so sending costs you nothing. Every card is listed on a signed, itemized receipt.
  6. Payment, usually within two business days of the cards arriving and checking out, by wire or check. For graded cards, we can pay before they ship once each certification checks out, if you prefer. Anything that is not as described goes back to you at our expense.

This is how we work as a general rule. Every collection is a little different, and the written offer is what governs each sale.

Gregory S. Ostrowski

You will be dealing with Gregory S. Ostrowski, who writes The Heirloom Index and has collected cards since he was a kid. Every inquiry is read and answered by him.

Tell us what you have
Baseball, basketball and football cards only. We don’t buy Pokémon or other trading card games, or racing cards.
A few lines are enough. We read every one.
Which sports (optional)
Any graded cards? (optional)

Nothing is committed by writing to us.

How we work. The rest of this site — the Market, the guides, the comparison of every auction house — is written the same way whether or not we are buying. An offer from us is not an appraisal, and if you would like to weigh it against selling at auction, what each house charges a seller is set out here.