The Diamond · Baseball

1951 Bowman #305

The Diamond Heirloom 25 Marquee · thin market
Recent salePSA 7 · $105,888September 2026 · Memory Lane ↗

This page records 461 verified public-auction sales of the 1951 Bowman #305 Willie Mays since 2004, by grade, each linked to its lot.

One set, two rookies: Mantle at #253, Mays at #305.

Read the full story ↓ See Willie Mays’s profile →

Willie Mays, in cards

1951–1973. Seven cards. Tap one for its story.

The Live Market
Observed from current eBay listings · 2026-11-20. Descriptive, never predictive.
Lowest Ask
$5,699
any grade · the cheapest qualifying listing on the board
Grades Tracked
10
each judged only against itself
PSA 5 Ask
$25,000
2 listed · PSA 5

Asking Prices by Grade

Each grade is judged only against its own grade, never blended. Graders grouped so they're comparable.
Grade 8
PSA 8$34,000Mid RangeBuy It Now1listedView on eBay
A single example currently offered: a standalone ask, not a liquid market price.
Grade 5at this grade: SGC +6.0% vs PSA
PSA 5$25,000Mid RangeBuy It Now2listedView on eBay
SGC 5$26,500Mid RangeBuy It Now1listedView on eBay
Grade 4.5
PSA 4.5$18,489Mid RangeBuy It Now1listedView on eBay
A single example currently offered: a standalone ask, not a liquid market price.
Grade 4at this grade: PSA +23.2% vs SGC
PSA 4$14,789Mid RangeBuy It Now3listedView on eBay
SGC 4$12,000Mid RangeBuy It Now1listedView on eBay
Grade 3.5
PSA 3.5$12,697Mid RangeBuy It Now1listedView on eBay
A single example currently offered: a standalone ask, not a liquid market price.
Grade 3
PSA 3$11,550Mid RangeBuy It Now4listedView on eBay
Grade 2.5
PSA 2.5$11,000Mid RangeBuy It Now2listedView on eBay
Grade 2
PSA 2$15,000Mid RangeBuy It Now1listedView on eBay
A single example currently offered: a standalone ask, not a liquid market price.
Grade 1.5at this grade: SGC +145.6% vs PSA
PSA 1.5$5,699Mid RangeBuy It Now2listedView on eBay
SGC 1.5$13,995Mid RangeBuy It Now1listedView on eBay
Grade 1
PSA 1$6,999Mid RangeBuy It Now1listedView on eBay
A single example currently offered: a standalone ask, not a liquid market price.

Sold Prices at Auction

Every dated public-auction sale we’ve verified for this card: realized prices only, each credited and linked. Hover a point for the sale; click to open the lot.
The last ten verified sales, newest first, with realized prices, buyer’s premium included.
SoldGradePriceHouse
September 2026PSA 7$105,888Memory Lane ↗
September 2026PSA 3$10,763Robert Edward Auctions ↗
September 2026PSA 8$268,400Heritage Auctions / HA.com ↗
August 2026CSG 5.5$18,910Heritage Auctions / HA.com ↗
August 2026PSA 7$53,680Heritage Auctions / HA.com ↗
August 2026PSA 3$17,835Robert Edward Auctions ↗
August 2026PSA 4$13,530Robert Edward Auctions ↗
August 2026PSA 4$12,915Robert Edward Auctions ↗
August 2026PSA 4$10,763Robert Edward Auctions ↗
August 2026PSA 2$10,148Robert Edward Auctions ↗
Sold prices by grade — 43 grades, newest sales first

1951 Bowman #305 GAI 9 — auction sales

1 verified sale: $26,290 · October 2005 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 PSA 9 — auction sales

3 verified sales; the most recent: $65,725 · October 2009 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $85,775 · May 2008 · Memory Lane  ·  $93,413 · April 2007 · Memory Lane

1951 Bowman #305 PSA 8.5 — auction sales

1 verified sale: $390,935 · August 2024 · Robert Edward Auctions

1951 Bowman #305 SGC 8.5 — auction sales

1 verified sale: $72,000 · November 2018 · Robert Edward Auctions

1951 Bowman #305 PSA 8 — auction sales

37 verified sales; the most recent: $268,400 · September 2026 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $176,900 · February 2026 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $213,500 · August 2025 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 PSA 7.5 — auction sales

3 verified sales; the most recent: $27,600 · August 2019 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $9,560 · May 2014 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $7,110 · May 2012 · Robert Edward Auctions

1951 Bowman #305 SGC 7.5 — auction sales

1 verified sale: $9,000 · May 2016 · Robert Edward Auctions

1951 Bowman #305 PSA 7 — auction sales

34 verified sales; the most recent: $105,888 · September 2026 · Memory Lane  ·  $53,680 · August 2026 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $54,900 · July 2026 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 SGC 7 — auction sales

9 verified sales; the most recent: $27,600 · February 2022 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $32,400 · November 2021 · Robert Edward Auctions  ·  $63,000 · March 2021 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 GAI 6.5 — auction sales

1 verified sale: $1,058 · July 2010 · Huggins & Scott Auctions

1951 Bowman #305 PSA 6.5 — auction sales

5 verified sales; the most recent: $47,580* · July 2026 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $35,380 · August 2025 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $28,800 · November 2024 · Robert Edward Auctions

1951 Bowman #305 SGC 6.5 — auction sales

2 verified sales; the most recent: $35,380 · October 2025 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $3,585 · October 2012 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 BVG 6 — auction sales

1 verified sale: $21,000 · May 2022 · Robert Edward Auctions

1951 Bowman #305 PSA 6 — auction sales

43 verified sales; the most recent: $76,875* · August 2026 · Robert Edward Auctions  ·  $29,280 · May 2026 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $31,720 · Spring 2026 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 SGC 6 — auction sales

5 verified sales; the most recent: $22,200 · August 2023 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $16,200 · August 2023 · Robert Edward Auctions  ·  $2,032 · November 2014 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 CSG 5.5 — auction sales

1 verified sale: $18,910 · August 2026 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 PSA 5.5 — auction sales

7 verified sales; the most recent: $16,200 · August 2025 · Robert Edward Auctions  ·  $25,200 · May 2023 · Robert Edward Auctions  ·  $23,400 · May 2022 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 SGC 5.5 — auction sales

3 verified sales; the most recent: $16,800 · November 2023 · Robert Edward Auctions  ·  $6,000 · November 2017 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $4,560 · May 2017 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 BVG 5 — auction sales

1 verified sale: $11,285 · May 2026 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 PSA 5 — auction sales

58 verified sales; the most recent: $16,605 · May 2026 · Robert Edward Auctions  ·  $17,690 · April 2026 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $21,350 · Spring 2026 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 SGC 5 — auction sales

13 verified sales; the most recent: $14,400 · January 2024 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $18,000 · July 2023 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $33,600 · January 2023 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 BVG 4.5 — auction sales

1 verified sale: $8,430 · November 2022 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 PSA 4.5 — auction sales

6 verified sales; the most recent: $10,675 · December 2025 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $10,800 · May 2023 · Robert Edward Auctions  ·  $11,400 · February 2023 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 SGC 4.5 — auction sales

8 verified sales; the most recent: $11,700 · May 2025 · Robert Edward Auctions  ·  $8,700 · October 2024 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $8,700 · July 2024 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 BVG 4 — auction sales

1 verified sale: $5,400 · October 2024 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 PSA 4 — auction sales

31 verified sales; the most recent: $13,530 · August 2026 · Robert Edward Auctions  ·  $12,915 · August 2026 · Robert Edward Auctions  ·  $10,763 · August 2026 · Robert Edward Auctions

1951 Bowman #305 SGC 4 — auction sales

22 verified sales; the most recent: $8,303 · November 2025 · Robert Edward Auctions  ·  $6,222 · October 2025 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $7,320 · March 2025 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 BVG 3.5 — auction sales

1 verified sale: $1,145 · November 2016 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 PSA 3.5 — auction sales

7 verified sales; the most recent: $10,148 · October 2025 · Robert Edward Auctions  ·  $9,150 · June 2025 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $7,200 · May 2025 · Robert Edward Auctions

1951 Bowman #305 SGC 3.5 — auction sales

3 verified sales; the most recent: $6,100 · June 2025 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $7,320 · January 2025 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $6,300 · May 2023 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 PSA 3 — auction sales

20 verified sales; the most recent: $10,763 · September 2026 · Robert Edward Auctions  ·  $17,835 · August 2026 · Robert Edward Auctions  ·  $11,295 · October 2025 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 SGC 3 — auction sales

36 verified sales; the most recent: $6,405 · November 2025 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $5,658 · November 2025 · Robert Edward Auctions  ·  $4,551 · November 2025 · Robert Edward Auctions

1951 Bowman #305 BVG 2.5 — auction sales

1 verified sale: $3,000 · May 2024 · Robert Edward Auctions

1951 Bowman #305 PSA 2.5 — auction sales

3 verified sales; the most recent: $3,690 · October 2020 · Huggins & Scott Auctions  ·  $1,680 · August 2018 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $1,560 · November 2017 · Huggins & Scott Auctions

1951 Bowman #305 SGC 2.5 — auction sales

12 verified sales; the most recent: $5,002 · May 2026 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $4,636 · May 2026 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $3,840 · November 2024 · Robert Edward Auctions

1951 Bowman #305 BVG 2 — auction sales

2 verified sales; the most recent: $4,080 · September 2023 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $3,960 · June 2022 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 CSG 2 — auction sales

1 verified sale: $4,200 · July 2022 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 PSA 2 — auction sales

19 verified sales; the most recent: $10,148 · August 2026 · Robert Edward Auctions  ·  $6,458 · August 2026 · Robert Edward Auctions  ·  $6,100 · June 2026 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 SGC 2 — auction sales

19 verified sales; the most recent: $5,002 · July 2026 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $5,978 · April 2026 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $3,416 · December 2025 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 PSA 1.5 — auction sales

6 verified sales; the most recent: $5,043 · June 2026 · Robert Edward Auctions  ·  $3,600 · October 2024 · Robert Edward Auctions  ·  $3,480 · May 2024 · Robert Edward Auctions

1951 Bowman #305 SGC 1.5 — auction sales

10 verified sales; the most recent: $3,360 · February 2025 · Robert Edward Auctions  ·  $4,080 · June 2024 · Robert Edward Auctions  ·  $3,840 · October 2021 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

1951 Bowman #305 PSA 1 — auction sales

10 verified sales; the most recent: $2,952 · November 2025 · Robert Edward Auctions  ·  $2,684 · July 2025 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $2,760 · May 2025 · Robert Edward Auctions

1951 Bowman #305 SGC 1 — auction sales

12 verified sales; the most recent: $3,050 · April 2026 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com  ·  $3,198 · September 2025 · Robert Edward Auctions  ·  $3,720 · September 2023 · Heritage Auctions / HA.com

* Sold with an MBA eye-appeal sticker (level shown). It is a real sale of this card, but not a like-for-like price for the grade alone.

Private acquisitions

Thinking of selling?

We buy blue-chip graded cards and whole collections: this card, any of the great cards across the hobby, or everything in the box. Single cards usually start at $5,000. If you are thinking of selling, we would be glad to hear from you.

Sell to Us → Or compare what each auction house charges →

Recent Sales

The most recent verified public-auction sales.
Recent auction-house sales
PSA 7 · $105,888Memory Lane · September 2026 · view the lot ↗
PSA 3 · $10,763Robert Edward Auctions · September 2026 · view the lot ↗
PSA 8 · $268,400Heritage Auctions / HA.com · September 2026 · view the lot ↗
Study more sold lots on eBay →
The sales listed here are completed auction-house results, each figure read from the house’s own lot page, buyer’s premium included. The eBay link opens that marketplace’s own sold & completed listings (auctions and Buy It Now), with reprints and novelties filtered out; sign-in may be required. Descriptive, never advice.
Why This Card
Why This Card

1951 Bowman #305 — The Rookie

Bowman · Card #305 · High-number series · His one true rookie

Willie Mays’s rookie card is #305 in 1951 Bowman, in the high numbers that reached stores late in the season he arrived.

He was called up from Minneapolis that May, hitting .477, and made his debut in Philadelphia on May 25, 1951. He went hitless in his first twelve at-bats. The first hit was a home run off Warren Spahn at the Polo Grounds. He was twenty, and by October he was the National League’s Rookie of the Year, with 20 home runs, and on deck when Bobby Thomson hit the pennant-winning home run on October 3.

Bowman issued the 1951 set in series through the year, which let it follow early-season trades, and it grew to 324 cards, the largest the company ever made, though its advertising had promised 340. Numbers 253 through 324 came last. Mickey Mantle is the first of them, at #253, and Mays is #305. The cards sold in one-cent and six-cent packs at candy stores and newsstands, and at 2-1/16 by 3⅛ inches they were longer than the year before.

One set, two rookies: Mantle at #253, Mays at #305.

Every front was painted from a black-and-white photograph supplied by the team. Mays’s lies on its side: he is shown from the chest up in a Giants uniform and cap, the bat resting on his right shoulder, looking back over his left, against a gold backdrop. His name sits in a small black box.

The Army took him after 34 games of 1952, and he did not return until 1954. That year he won the batting title at .345, the Most Valuable Player award, and, on September 29, made the catch off Vic Wertz that the game still calls The Catch. He finished with 660 home runs. His 1952 Topps card has its own following. This is the first.

The high numbers are hard to find well centered from top to bottom, and gum and wax stains are common on 1951 Bowmans.

Set
1951 Bowman · 324 cards
Card
#305 · high number (#253–324)
The front
A painting, on its side
Set-mate
The Mantle rookie, #253
Rookie year
Rookie of the Year; 20 HR
The challenge
Top-to-bottom centering

Few will ever own this one, but every great collection starts somewhere.

Begin the search on eBay →
A curated eBay search for this card and others like it. The rarest of these seldom come to market. As an eBay Partner, the Heirloom Index may earn from qualifying purchases; it never changes the price you pay.
Follow cards like this one Weekend Reading, most Fridays: what the finest cards actually sold for that week, read closely, and one story told properly. Free. Sign up below ↓
Own this card, or just inherited one? Read what to do before you sell anything. If you are thinking of selling, we would be glad to hear from you.