The Market · The Legends
The Legends · Baseball

Willie Mays

Willie Mays could beat a team five ways: with his average, his power, his legs, his arm and his glove. He did it from 1951 to 1973, finished with 660 home runs and 12 Gold Gloves, and his first card comes from the scarce last series of the 1951 Bowman set.

Willie Mays, in cards

1951–1973. Seven cards. Tap one for its story.

The card we follow
1951 Bowman #305
See today’s listings on eBay →
Observed on eBay. We are not the seller. As an eBay Partner, we may earn from qualifying purchases.
Own one of these, or another great card? We buy blue-chip graded cards and whole collections →

Scouts grade a position player on five things: hitting for average, hitting for power, running, throwing and fielding. Willie Mays was the rare player at the top of the scale on all five, and he played center field with an ease that made the hardest position on the field look like play.

He was born in Westfield, Alabama, in 1931, and was in the outfield for the Birmingham Black Barons as a teenager. The Giants brought him up in 1951 and he was Rookie of the Year. The Army took most of 1952 and all of 1953. He came back in 1954, won the batting title at .345, and was Most Valuable Player. The second MVP came in 1965, eleven years later.

Game 1, 1954 World Series: tied 2–2 in the eighth, two on, nobody out, and a drive to the deepest part of the Polo Grounds.

Vic Wertz hit it, by the Hall of Fame's estimate some 460 feet. Mays ran it down with his back to the plate, caught it over his shoulder, spun and threw to hold the runners. The Giants won the game and swept Cleveland. It is still called simply The Catch.

The totals came over twenty-two seasons: 660 home runs, more than 3,000 hits, 24 All-Star selections, 12 Gold Gloves, all of them in center field. He finished with the Mets in 1973, back in New York where he had started.

His rookie card is number 305 in the 1951 Bowman set. Bowman's cards that year were press photographs finished with painted color, and Mays falls in the high-number series, the 72 cards added late in the run and printed in smaller numbers, which are scarce today. Mantle's rookie card sits in the same series.

He died in June 2024, at ninety-three. People who saw him play still describe the joy before they get to the numbers.

Own one of these, or just inherited one? Read what to do before you sell anything.
The Quiz
Which collector are you?
Find your collector type →
Keep wandering: The Market · or all of The Diamond.