The most famous trading card in the world, and very nearly one that never existed. The American Tobacco Company began printing Honus Wagner into its T206 series in 1909, then stopped when he refused his permission. Hobby estimates of how many survive begin at about fifty; the Hall of Fame says no one knows.
The American Tobacco Company issued the T206 cards from 1909 to 1911 to advertise its cigarette and tobacco brands, one small lithographed card, about 1-7/16 by 2-5/8 inches, slipped into a pack of cigarettes. Jefferson Burdick, whose collection is now at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, gave the series its name. Wagner was added partway through the first printing in 1909. His card shows him from the chest up against a bright, flat background, over the caption WAGNER, PITTSBURG, the city's official spelling from 1891 until 1911. Nearly every surviving copy carries a Sweet Caporal back; two or three are Piedmonts.
The company asked local sportswriters to get each player's consent. In Pittsburgh the man was John Gruber, the Pirates' official scorer, and Wagner sent the request back with a check to cover Gruber's fee and a note saying he did not want his picture in cigarettes. Why has never been settled. His family has said he did not want children buying cigarettes; others think he wanted to be paid; two historians have pointed out that cigarettes were held in low esteem beside other tobacco, and Wagner himself smoked cigars, chewed, and disliked cigarettes. The author Dave Jamieson, writing for the Met, put it simply: no one knows for certain.
That fall Wagner's Pirates won 110 games and met Ty Cobb's Tigers in the World Series. Pittsburgh won in seven. Wagner hit .333 and stole six bases; Cobb hit .231. It was the year of Wagner's seventh batting title, of eight. In 1936, when the Hall of Fame held its first election, he received 215 of 226 votes, tied with Babe Ruth for second behind Cobb.
The card's reputation came early. A Newark newspaper called it the hardest card to get in 1930, and in 1941 Burdick named Wagner and Eddie Plank the scarcest cards in the set. The Met holds one in the Burdick Collection, and the Hall of Fame keeps two, one with a thumbtack hole above his head. The best known of all, the copy Wayne Gretzky bought in 1991, carries its own footnote: in 2013 the dealer who had handled it in the 1980s admitted to trimming it.
Honus Wagner hit .328 over twenty-one seasons, most of them as Pittsburgh's shortstop, and joined the Hall of Fame's first class. His T206 trades too seldom for a live tile to say anything honest, which is why he lives here.
It is featured in the Vault as a card to be admired and understood, not chased on a given afternoon. No live price, no link to buy. Just the history.
