The card many collectors treat as Joe DiMaggio's rookie, from the 1938 Goudey set the hobby calls Heads-Up for its real photographs of players' heads set on drawn cartoon bodies. He appears twice in it, once against a plain background (#250) and once with cartoons sketched around him (#274), three seasons before the fifty-six-game hitting streak that still stands.
Goudey's 1938 set picked up its numbering where the 1933 set had ended, at #241, and ran to #288: 48 cards, but only 24 players, each shown twice from the same photograph. The design gave the set its name. A real photograph of the player's head sits on a small drawn cartoon body, over a colored strip with his name and team. Numbers 241 to 264 have nothing else on them; numbers 265 to 288 show the same players again with cartoons and comments drawn around them. The backs, with statistics and a biography, promised a series of 312 cards. It stopped at 288.
DiMaggio is #250, on a plain background, in the first series, and #274, surrounded by drawings, in the second. Sports Illustrated notes that #274 includes a cartoon of the Hall of Fame, a year before the building opened in Cooperstown. Collectors accept either card; the difference between the two series is small.
Whether either is his rookie card is the hobby's argument. He had appeared as DeMaggio on Zee-Nut cards with the San Francisco Seals, and in 1936 Goudey's own Canadian company, World Wide Gum of Montreal, put him in a set with English and French backs. Goudey also offered him in 1936 as a premium photograph for wrappers, and National Chicle, O-Pee-Chee and a set of flip books had him before 1938. Pre-War Cards says most collectors pick the 1936 World Wide Gum; Sports Illustrated says the 1938 Goudey, or something earlier.
He had made his debut on May 3, 1936, and the Yankees won the World Series that fall, the first of four in a row. In 1937 he hit .346 with 46 home runs and 167 runs batted in, and led the majors in home runs and runs. In 1938 he hit .324 with 32. Three years later, from May 15 to July 17, 1941, he hit safely in fifty-six straight games, passing Willie Keeler's old record on July 2. No one has matched it. He was elected to the Hall of Fame in 1955.
Which DiMaggio counts as his rookie card is argued over more than most, and the Heads-Up trades too seldom for a live tile to say anything honest, so his story is told here.
It is featured in the Vault as a card to be admired and understood, not chased on a given afternoon. No live price, no link to buy. Just the history.
