Sell to Us · Maryland and nearby
Selling a baseball card collection in Maryland and nearby
We buy baseball, basketball and football cards, graded or raw, from a single card to a whole collection. Based in Annapolis, we see collections in person across Maryland, Washington, D.C., Virginia, Delaware, Pennsylvania and New Jersey.
What we buy
- Vintage stars and rookie cards, especially from before 1980, in any condition.
- Graded cards from PSA, SGC or Beckett, and raw cards just as they are. Nothing needs grading first.
- Whole collections: estates, inherited boxes, binders, and the shoebox that has been in the closet for decades.
- Modern cards at the high end, the blue-chip names and the rare parallels.
We don’t buy Pokémon or other trading card games, or racing cards. If what you have isn’t a fit, we will tell you so and point you somewhere that suits it better.
How we buy
- Tell us what you have. A few lines, or a photo of the cards laid out on a table.
- We write back personally, usually within two business days, and arrange a visit if it helps.
- A written offer. One clear figure, card by card or for the lot, good for 14 days. We’ll provide our best offer, and you’re welcome to get a second opinion.
- We pay before you ship. By PayPal Goods & Services, with the fees on us, plus a prepaid, fully insured shipping label. A check, a wire or a meeting in person works too.
- Every card on a signed, itemized receipt.
Before you sell to anyone
If you are looking to sell baseball cards for cash near you, an afternoon of homework first is worth it, whoever you end up selling to. Sort the collection by decade, look up what the stars have actually sold for, and read every way to sell a collection, with what each one costs. If the cards came to you from someone else, start with what to do with an inherited card collection.

You will be dealing with Gregory Ostrowski, who writes The Heirloom Index and has collected cards since he was a kid. Every inquiry is read and answered by him.