Weekend Reading is a short Friday column on the stories behind the cards people collect and what they bring at auction. This week starts with a photograph, the one Topps used for Jim Brown’s rookie card, and ends with a Mantle that never sold.
Jim Brown’s Photograph, $146,400
In the summer of 1957 the Browns’ team photographer, Henry Barr, took pictures of a rookie fullback from Syracuse at training camp. One of them became Jim Brown’s rookie card, the 1958 Topps No. 62, one of the thirty-nine cards we follow. On Wednesday, November 4, an original print of that photograph sold at Goldin for $146,400, after 35 bids. We pointed to it in On the Block on October 30.
It’s hard not to love a piece of sports Americana like this. The card is how most of us met Jim Brown, and this photograph is where the card came from. One small thing I’ve always enjoyed: Topps printed his name on the front as JIMMY BROWN.

Here’s the bit worth knowing if you ever shop for photographs. Goldin sold the print as a Type I, which is PSA’s term for a first-generation photograph, printed from the original negative within about two years of when the picture was taken. Goldin says PSA has certified only four Type I prints of this one. On the back it carries Barr’s copyright stamp and an official Cleveland Browns stamp, and those stamps are a big part of how anyone can say when it was printed and by whom.
For scale, a 1958 Topps Jim Brown in PSA 7 sold at Heritage on October 25 for $5,856. The photograph brought as much as twenty-five of the cards made from it.
The same sale was led by Michael Jordan’s foul-line dunk from the 1988 Slam Dunk Contest, a signed Type I by the Bulls’ team photographer, Bill Smith, at $179,340. A signed 1996 photograph of Kobe Bryant, taken before his first NBA game, brought $65,011, which Sports Collectors Daily called a record for any Bryant photograph sold at public auction.

Mickey Mantle, $390,877, Off-Center
On October 27, in our Tuesday post on what was closing, we named a 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle, No. 311, graded PSA 8 (OC), at Love of the Game. It sold on November 1 for $390,877, according to Sports Illustrated.
Those two letters in parentheses do a lot of work. OC means off-center. PSA adds it when a card earns the grade on everything else, the corners, the edges and the surface, but the picture sits too far to one side for that number. The label still says 8. The OC says: except for the centering.
Here’s what that costs. Heritage has sold the same card in PSA 8 with no qualifier twice in the past year, in December 2025 and again in July, for $1,555,500 both times. Same card, same number on the label, and the OC copy brought about a quarter of that.

If a slab ever looks priced too well for its grade, look for letters after the number: OC for off-center, MC for miscut, ST for staining. That’s usually the reason.
The same sale also closed out the 1952 Topps five-cent pack graded PSA 7 that we mentioned in On the Block on October 30. PostWarCards reported it at $147,319.
The $50 Million Mantle That Never Sold
The same week, a much bigger Mantle number went around. A podcaster, Patrick Bet-David, said a PSA 10 1952 Topps Mantle had sold privately for $50 million, and that he had been involved as a possible buyer. Ken Goldin, the founder of Goldin, called it false news. Michael Osacky of PSA told Men’s Journal there was no record of any such sale. Only three PSA 10s of the card are known.
For scale, the most anyone has paid for a 1952 Topps Mantle in public is $12.6 million, for a copy graded SGC 9.5, at Heritage in August 2022.
Private sales are real, and some big ones never get announced. But a number with no house, no buyer and no paperwork behind it is a story about a sale, not a sale. My habit before I repeat any big figure is to ask two things: where did it sell, and who says so? The $390,877 above has an answer to both. The $50 million doesn’t.
On the Block
Lelands, bidding opens November 15, through December 5. In the Fall Classic catalog, an original 1939 photograph signed by both Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig, from July 4, 1939, the day of Gehrig’s “Luckiest Man” speech, certified by PSA as a Type I. Also in the sale: a 1999 Metal Universe Gem Masters Derek Jeter, No. 97, the only one made, graded PSA 8 this year after 27 years out of a holder.
Collector Investor Auctions, closes November 15 from 9:10pm ET. A 1958 Topps Jim Brown, No. 62, in SGC 5: the card that Henry Barr’s photograph became.
From around the hobby
Bobby Orr’s Chicago Blackhawks Hockey Cards (Sports Collectors Daily). His short stay in Chicago, and the airbrushed Bruins photos on the cards that followed.
The Education Inside a Wax Pack (Sports Collectors Daily). How the backs of old cards taught a generation of kids their arithmetic and geography without anyone meaning them to.
Everything this week came down to what was written on the thing. Two stamps on the back of a 1957 print tell you who made it and when. Two letters on a Mantle’s label explain most of a gap of more than $1.1 million. And the $50 million Mantle has nothing written down anywhere. Whatever you’re looking at, a photograph, a slab or a headline, read the small print first. It usually tells you more than the big number does.
— Greg

